-

-
Although this could very well be a picture of me finding a new treasure at a favorite nursery, it's actually an illustration by David Catrow for a children's book called Plantzilla.

Thursday, September 19, 2013

A Tale of Two Oaks. My favorite plant in the garden (This Week.)

O.K. it's really just a comparison of two interesting oaks, Quercus robur 'Filicifolia' and Quercus dentata 'Pinnatifida.' The first being brand new to me as I just purchased it from none other than Dancing Oakes Nursery at the recent Heronswood sale and the second being an old and still greatly admired friend that I bought years ago from Heronswood Nursery.   My pal Loree asked me about the new oak as she was contemplating a Q. dentata 'Pinnatifida' for an area of her garden that she'll be clearing out but also liked the foliage of Q. robur 'Filicifolia.'  To be a lazy friend and an even lazier blogger, I've made a post out of the comparison that I was going to do anyway for my own edification.

Here's what little I know and some information borrowed from Michigan State University's Plant Encyclopedia  Quercus robur 'Filicifolia' is an English Oak cultivar and is also known  as cut leaf oak and fern leaf oak. 

Distribution:  Europe, N. Africa, and western Asia.

Hardiness Zone:  USDA Zones 4-8  

Size:   75-100 ft. tall, with a similar spread.

Form:   Deciduous. A large, open, wide-spreading tree, with heavy limbs and a short, massive trunk.

Bark:   Bark grayish brown, becoming deeply fissured with age.

Stem/Bud: 

Leaves:   Deciduous. A large, open, wide-spreading tree, with heavy limbs and a short, massive trunk.

Fall Color:   Fall color is brownish to red.

Flower:   Plants are monoecious. Male flowers are borne in clustered, pendent catkins; the females are borne solitary, or in a few-flowered spike in the axils of the new leaves.

Fruit:   Fruit is an acorn, l-2 inches long, oblong to oval, enclosed about l/3 by bowl-like, thick, woody, knobbycap, borne on a long, slender stalk. Raw acorns are poisonous.

Uses:   Specimen. Dry sites.

Problems:   Acorns contain tannic acids that are posionous (they were used in past to tan leather). The tannic acids msut be leached or boiled out before they are eaten.

Notes:    Has longer acorns than the other oaks we study.

Notes 2:   Leafs out late in spring. Shade tree.





Q. dentata 'Pinnatifida' has much larger leaves that sometimes appear to have a golden cast to them.  There are some great pictures of a 40 year old specimen of this one along with an interesting comment here.  Mostly, I remember my glee at first seeing this for the first time.  The leaves were glowing beautifully in the summer sunshine and my heart began pounding the way it does when I see a glorious plant for the first time.  I believe in love at first sight!


An informative post from the JC Raulston Arboretum can be found here. My personal experience with this one is that it grows very slowly but surely but the foliage is thrilling.  One site said 10 feet tall by 3 feet wide in 10 years.  I think that's fairly optimistic.  
 
 There's lots of great information about this one at Plant Lust.

Here's the trowel again for scale.  A Japanese/Korean native, the Emperor oak is pretty spectacular of foliage.  Louis the Plant Geek is fond of it's pink spring foliage.  See his entry here.  I've been seeing this called a rare and even very rare tree yet there seems to be a lot of writing about it and I've seen it for sale in a few places.

Those are some big, interesting-looking leaves!  ("This is the one that you want" he whispered to his agave-loving friend.) I remember Dan Hinkley waxing poetic about this somewhere but can't put my finger on the source at the moment. 
So enamored of the leaves am I that in the fall as they drop, some are gathered and brought inside to appreciate through the winter.

Anyway, if you're looking for an oak with unusual leaves, these two should be on your short list unless you want to sit in the shade of said tree in your lifetime.  In that case, maybe I could show you something in a paulownia or poplar.

My favorite plant in the garden this week is the brainchild of Loree at Danger Garden.  Follow the link to see this weeks favorite plants of other gardeners.

23 comments:

  1. They're both beauts with a slight preference for the Pinnatifida. I miss the one we had before the fire, ought to reintroduce another one again. We also found it needed staking for it to grow upright.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I'm so sorry you lost this plant in the fire! It's true, these are quite floppy when young!

      Delete
  2. Both lovely looking trees! I remember seeing a lace-leaf oak at the Lan Su Garden in Portland, maybe not one of these, but it was a good size and quite beautiful. Personally I prefer maple trees to oak trees in general. What a great idea for a post! I tried to convince myself when I first started blogging that it was "just for my own edification," but quickly realized it rally was more social than that.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. They are nice. Maples are wonderful trees and so varied but oaks are interesting too. I was fascinated with acorns as a young kid in Vermont! Blogging is way social isn't it.

      Delete
  3. Thank you for this fabulous post! I really had no idea they were such slow growers, this is valuable information as I plan what to do with that space. I will still include one (and yes, I do think the 'Pinnatifida' is the one for me) but I guess I'll need to come up with something else to be the fast growing BIG something in the former privet-lands (yes I can hear you thinking "pineapple broom...I tried to get you to buy one...").

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. A good friend never says I told you so and I admire the effect of the careful choices you make. I wish some of your restraint would rub off on me! Anyway, you know where the pineapple broom is if you decide that it's the plant for you.

      Delete
  4. Beautiful foliage! I love oak trees! I sometimes dream of having a southern live oak tree covered in spanish moss!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Those Spanish moss covered oaks in the south are fabulous aren't they. It's a nice dream Louis!

      Delete
  5. I love the idea of a comparison post such as this one, it's brilliant and informative.
    Oak leafs are beautifully shaped although I'm not sure I could fit one of these trees in my garden. Does Oakleaf Hydrangea count? :-) Any chance the Pinnatifida would do well in a pot?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I grow Pinnatifida in pots and they thrive (slowly, very slowly.) Sun and especially good drainage are the most important things to make this oak happy. Oakleaf Hydrangea most definitely counts. You could always attach little acorns to it with glue.

      Delete
  6. Dancing Oaks has wide selection of unusual oaks (surprise! surprise!). The variety was a revelation to this girl who lived for many years in an oak grove. It's getting late in life to invest in such a slow grower, but what the heck...I need one!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. You really owe it to yourself to get one! Dancing oaks also had another interesting variety with rather large leaves that I almost got as well. Really, by the time these are tall enough to worry about, I'll be long gone, right?

      Delete
  7. I agree, Peter! Interesting shape of the leaves. It's really favorite plant!

    ReplyDelete
  8. Good post, I never heard of cutleaf oaks. I would be interested in seeing the fall color.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. You probably wouldn't. The Pinatafida just gets a little brown. Fortunately, the leaves of this oak don't hang on looking all brown and dead all winter like some oak leaves do.

      Delete
  9. Oak trees are just a dream for me, but at least I am surrounded by them everywhere here in Norcal.
    As you mentioned DH's waxing (verbal waxing of course) I looked through a few of my beloved Heronswood catalogs, and in the 2004 issue he wrote "There are beautiful trees and magnificent oaks, and fantastic foliage, and then there is this fast growing tree which in beauty rises above all." He closes the description by stating "In my estimation, one of the most sensational trees to be made available in many years."

    An excellent word--sensational !

    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=oWO1vX0AjCc


    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Yes! Those are the words that made me purchase my first Pinatafida! I've got 90's catalogs up through 2001 but I don't remember what I did with the later ones. They're around here somewhere. Thank you for finding that description for me! You're sensational! (Loved the clip!)

      Delete
  10. Didn't know these incredible oaks existed! I'll have to search for them! they would look great in my garden! thanks for your comparison!

    ReplyDelete
  11. Very interesting leaves. However, even though I knew they were slow growing, I didn't realize that they might only get 10 ft tall in 10 years! Still, having anything that might eventually (even though not in my lifetime) grow to 100 ft is a bit scary!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Don't be frightened, the big tree will not hurt you! It may shade out all of your rose bushes but you it will leave alone.

      Delete
  12. Where can I get one? Need one desperately!!

    ReplyDelete

Thanks so much for taking the time to comment! I love to hear your thoughts.